Does Acupuncture Really Work?

Some people have claimed that acupuncture has helped them with conditions like rheumatoid arthritis.
In acupuncture treatments, needles are used to penetrate the skin in order to stimulate very specific locations of the body.
Some people find that the local Chinatown is a good place to look for an acupuncturist.
Acupuncture has been performed in China for thousands of years to treat pain and numerous other ailments.
Article Details
  • Written By: Tricia Ellis-Christensen
  • Edited By: O. Wallace
  • Images By: Www.doglikehorse.com, Max Tactic, Guillaume Baviere, Idmanjoe
  • Last Modified Date: 25 October 2014
  • Copyright Protected:
    2003-2014
    Conjecture Corporation
  • Print this Article

Trying to answer whether acupuncture actually works is very challenging. First, the practice is used in a broad variety of applications, and dedicated practitioners may claim that the rebalance of qi, the body’s energy field, will fix almost anything. This is clearly not true, and failure to see results for many different types of medical conditions has been proven.

Still, a blanket "no" to the question of whether acupuncture actually works is not easy to give either. Some scientific tests have shown some limited effectiveness in treating a few conditions. Further, there are the many people who anecdotally claim this treatment helped them with conditions like rheumatoid arthritis, high blood pressure, generalized anxiety disorder, and the list goes on.

The US National Institute of Health concluded in 1998 that this treatment may have some benefits and its use might be expanded to traditional medicine in some applications. However, the report also concluded more studies were required.

In 1999, the British Medical Journal examined close to 50 trials of acupuncture given to enhance healing after stroke. The trials showed effectiveness ranging from mild to very effective. Cecil Adams, writer of The Straight Dope concludes Chinese researchers only published positive results. That’s a fairly wide leap to take when no evidence exists that results had been tampered with.

Ad

However, Adams does point out that the American Journal of Acupuncture shows that research fails to prove its effectiveness. The conclusion of the Journal is that clinical trials may not be an adequate test of a practice with a very different type of methodology and philosophy.

In other words, Eastern medicine may require different clinical trials than Western medicine. This conclusion sounds a bit strange, and weakens the argument that acupuncture actually works. If it does, it should be clinically verifiable.

Where people have not benefited from Western medicine, they often look to alternative solutions like acupuncture. It cannot be denied that some people benefit from this treatment. It is, however, hard to say how much benefit one will achieve, if any. Sometimes belief that something will work, works as well as the treatment, which is called the placebo effect. When people have lost faith in traditional medicine, they may find their condition improves when nontraditional medicine is tried.

Simply being told that acupuncture will help, when Western doctors offer no solutions is often enough for the mind to mentally improve someone’s condition, especially when pain-related. This is because perception is definitely linked to the amount of pain one feels. In fact, many clinics now offer a cognitive behavioral approach to pain management, which has clinically been proven more effective than acupuncture.

Ad

More from Wisegeek

You might also Like

Discuss this Article

anon942112
Post 7

I have had three treatments so far for the Osteoarthritis in my neck and leg, along with sciatica in my leg and back and disk problems in my back. With each treatment I have greatly improved. I'm looking forward to my fourth treatment. It really works. I like traditional Chinese medicine and herbs.

anon133947
Post 5

The author of this article doesn't appear to understand how meta analysis works. The distribution should be a bell curve - that it is not constitutes very good evidence of sampling bias.

anon128896
Post 4

I haven't tried acupuncture, but just wanted to ask a question to skeptics and/or scientists who view chi and qi as superstitious beliefs: Does the human body (or all matter for that point) not produce/radiate energy? Answer: Yes. Do humans have the physical ability/sense to perceive these energies? Answer: Some claim to be able to, but for the most part, no.

So my point is that everything is composed of energy, and we, as humans, can only perceive a very tiny fraction of all radiant energy without the use of outside, technological devices.

I don't find it so far-fetched that manipulation of bodily energies through more holistic means is actually "un-scientific". In fact I propose that much of what is considered superstition or myth are actually interpretations of the infinite amount/spectrums of energies we are surrounded by, composed of, and bathed in every day.

Science and "myth" are not so far apart in my opinion, with the former being man's tool to understand and shed away the mythos of the unexplained. Science (most notably medical) has a very long way to go in bridging the gap between the perceived physical world and the infinite, metaphysical existence of universal energies.

anon122868
Post 3

Of course it works. read the research instead of being a typical allopath sympathizer.

anon34542
Post 2

Honestly, I just had my first treatment of acupuncture yesterday for chronic pain. I woke up this morning feeling better than I have in such a *long* time - she even made problems I didn't address feel better. I am pretty open minded and love the fact that acupuncture is not covering up your pain with a pill but it seems to help release energy or the magic in ya - Oh my Gosh! I love it - so far. You don't even really feel the needles much and it's *so* relaxing - so worth it! I feel *so* good!!

anon7211
Post 1

I was suffering from severe chronic back pain (middle area of my back) for 2 years, even after multiple tests doctors could not fix my back problem. I was told about acupuncture and tried it, WOW did it ever work, I have been pain free for 5 yrs. now and going strong. IT REALLY DOES WORK.

Yours truly: believer

Post your comments

Post Anonymously

Login

username
password
forgot password?

Register

username
password
confirm
email