Is it Safe to Combine Melatonin and Valerian?

The effects of melatonin and valerian should be tested individually before combining them as a sleep aid.
Melatonin supplements have been linked to nightmares and vivid dreams.
Melatonin and valerian are both naturally occurring compounds known to aid sleep.
Melatonin poses little risk of overdose.
Article Details
  • Written By: S. Berger
  • Edited By: Shereen Skola
  • Last Modified Date: 24 October 2014
  • Copyright Protected:
    2003-2014
    Conjecture Corporation
  • Print this Article

Melatonin and valerian are two naturally occurring compounds that are often used as sleep aids. They are both alternatives for people wishing to avoid stronger pharmaceutical sleeping pills. One of the more common questions regarding these substances is whether it is safe to combine them. These substances can usually be combined safely in moderate amounts, but it is important to consider the safety profile of each before mixing them.

With regard to dosage, both melatonin and valerian pose little threat of harm from excessive doses. Individuals can respond quite differently to identical doses of the same supplement, however, so taking the minimal amount of these compounds to achieve the desired effect is usually the safest way to begin. Doing so can help to avoid any potential adverse effects.

Clinical studies performed by German and American universities have revealed the minimum dosages of melatonin and valerian needed to induce sleep. Valerian is usually effective at 450 milligrams (mg) to 600 mg, without leaving most people feeling tired the next day. This dosage is for a standardized extract of the herb, or a preparation that has been scientifically determined to contain a certain amount of an active compound. Active dosages for melatonin are in the range of 0.3 mg to 5 mg.

Ad

Supplements like melatonin and valerian may sometimes have stronger effects taken together than would be expected. For this reason dosages should be decreased when combining these supplements. To use both compounds safely with the least possible side effects, users may cut the dosage of each in half on the first night. Dosages can be slowly increased each night until the proper combination is found.

Doctors that specialize in sleep problems have noted that while combining melatonin and valerian is usually safe for most people, it may not be the best option for dealing with sleep problems. These types of supplements should be considered short-term solutions to be taken as occasional sleep aids, they caution. Neither compound causes physical dependence, but mixing the two may not always be necessary.

Before combining melatonin and valerian, some doctors recommend becoming familiar with the effects of both compounds individually. For some people, just one or the other may be needed to induce sleep. Consulting a medical professional to determine the underlying reason for poor sleep can also help relieve sleep problems without having to take these compounds on a nightly basis.

Ad

More from Wisegeek

You might also Like

Discuss this Article

SarahGen
Post 3

@fBoyle-- I have taken them together before, I didn't have any major issues. I remember having some stomach upset but I have no idea if it was due to melatonin and valerian.

I actually slept much better (fell asleep quickly and stayed asleep until morning) when I took both melatonin and valerian. The results were definitely better than the results of taking one alone.

fify
Post 2

@fBoyle-- That's actually a common problem with melatonin. I think that almost everyone who takes melatonin for more than a week will start building some tolerance to it. Using some valerian in addition may certainly be helpful. But have you tried valerian on its own before? Valerian on its own might actually work well enough for you. You might not even need the melatonin.

If melatonin is no longer working, I suggest trying valerian first. If you're not getting the results you want with valerian, you might want to add a low dose of melatonin and see how it works out. But like the article said, go slow. Start with very low doses and slowly increase them if necessary and never go above the daily recommended dose for either. Ask a doctor if you have concerns.

fBoyle
Post 1

I've been taking melatonin to help me sleep. It was working great at first, but I seem to have developed some tolerance to it because I need a higher dose to fall asleep. I'm thinking of using a low dose of melatonin but also adding valerian so that I can fall asleep more easily. Is this a good idea?

Is anyone here using melatonin and valerian together for sleep?

Post your comments

Post Anonymously

Login

username
password
forgot password?

Register

username
password
confirm
email